Differences Between ARFID vs. Picky Eating

Schedule a Consult
Close up view of small snowdrops flower growing among dry leaves in forest. First spring plants in woods.

The Kahm Center, renowned for its expertise in treating eating disorders, provides in-depth insights into the differences between Avoidant/Restrictive Food Intake Disorder (ARFID) and picky eating. This exploration is particularly relevant given that a majority of patients with ARFID have reported fears of gastrointestinal (GI) symptoms as a fundamental reason for their food avoidance and dietary restrictions. This article aims to elucidate these differences from a clinical perspective, emphasizing the Kahm Center's approach in managing these conditions through specialized programs like Intensive Outpatient Programs (IOP) and Partial Hospitalization Programs (PHP).

The distinction between ARFID and picky eating is critical in the context of treatment and management. While picky eating is often viewed as a developmental phase in children, ARFID presents a more complex challenge, often rooted in deep-seated fears and anxieties about the physical consequences of eating. The Kahm Center's treatment strategies are designed to address these specific fears and the unique needs of individuals with ARFID, distinguishing it from the more general approach often suitable for picky eating. This tailored approach underscores the importance of specialized care for those with ARFID, considering the significant impact of these GI symptom-related fears on their eating behaviors.

Definition and Clinical Profile of ARFID

Avoidant/Restrictive Food Intake Disorder (ARFID), recognized in the DSM-5, is identified by a marked disruption in normal eating patterns. The clinical characteristics of ARFID include:

  • Inadequate Nutritional Intake: This manifests as significant weight loss or in children, a failure to achieve expected weight gain. The issue stems from insufficient intake of nutrients and calories.
  • Nutritional Deficiencies: Due to limited food intake, individuals with ARFID often experience deficiencies in essential nutrients, which can lead to various health complications.
  • Dependence on Supplemental Nutrition: Many with ARFID rely on enteral feeding or oral nutritional supplements to meet their basic dietary needs.
  • Social Functioning Impairment: ARFID significantly affects social interactions and daily activities, often linked to the eating disorder's restrictive nature.

Distinctly, ARFID does not involve concerns about body weight or shape that are typical in other eating disorders. It may arise from a general disinterest in eating, sensory-based food aversions, or anxiety about the consequences of eating certain foods.

If you’re concerned you or a loved one could have ARFID, take our ARFID test to explore behaviors and signs associated with an ARFID diagnosis.

Overview of Picky Eating

Picky eating, a common phenomenon in children, involves a limited and selective range of food preferences, often accompanied by a reluctance to try new foods. Typically seen as a developmental phase, picky eating usually does not lead to severe nutritional deficiencies or significant weight loss, thereby not hindering normal growth and development. While it may be a concern for parents, picky eating generally does not entail the same long-term health implications as more severe eating disorders.

Recent findings indicate a notable overlap in the eating difficulties, behavioral problems, and sensory profiles among children with picky eating, Avoidant/Restrictive Food Intake Disorder (ARFID), and Autism Spectrum Disorder (ASD). This overlap suggests that while picky eating is often a benign and transient phase in childhood development, it can, in some cases, be indicative of more complex issues related to sensory sensitivities or behavioral challenges. These findings underscore the importance of a nuanced understanding of a child’s eating behaviors and the potential need for further evaluation in cases where eating difficulties are persistent and accompanied by other developmental or behavioral concerns.

Clinical Distinction Between ARFID and Picky Eating

Severity and Health Impact

ARFID is notably more severe than picky eating, characterized by substantial nutritional deficiencies that can lead to serious health issues if unaddressed. In contrast, picky eating generally leads to less severe health outcomes and rarely results in significant nutritional gaps or medical concerns.

Anxiety Association

A major distinguishing factor is the association with anxiety. ARFID is often linked with high levels of anxiety or fear related to eating or sensory experiences of food. This anxiety can be so severe that it significantly hampers an individual's ability to consume a varied diet. Picky eating, meanwhile, is usually not associated with this level of anxiety, often stemming more from personal food preferences than psychological distress.

Age and Duration

ARFID can affect individuals at any age and tends to be a more enduring condition, sometimes persisting into adulthood without proper treatment. Picky eating is predominantly observed in childhood and often resolves as the child grows, making it less likely to continue into later life stages.

Necessity for Intervention

ARFID typically requires comprehensive professional intervention, involving both nutritional and psychological support. Picky eating, on the other hand, usually does not require such extensive intervention. It can often be addressed with dietary guidance and encouragement to try new foods.

An important aspect of understanding ARFID, especially in the context of picky eating, is recognizing that picky eaters who display symptoms of ARFID can be differentiated from those without these symptoms. This differentiation is based on specific eating behaviors and the presence of increased internal distress, symptoms resembling obsessive-compulsive disorder (OCD), and a more significant impact on their quality of life related to eating. These factors are crucial in identifying and treating ARFID effectively, distinguishing it from more typical picky eating behaviors.

Treatment Modalities at Kahm Center - ARFID Treatment

At the Kahm Center, the treatment of ARFID and picky eating is anchored in a comprehensive and adaptive approach, tailored to the unique needs of each patient. The center's strategies include:

  • Personalized Treatment Plans: Recognizing the individuality of each case, the center crafts treatment plans that are specifically tailored to the patient's needs. These plans are dynamic and are adjusted based on the patient's progress and specific challenges encountered during the treatment process.
  • Multidisciplinary Approach: The treatment involves a collaborative effort from a diverse team of professionals. This team typically includes therapists, dietitians, and medical professionals, ensuring a holistic approach to treatment that addresses all aspects of the patient's condition, including physical health, nutritional status, and mental well-being.
  • Nutritional Guidance: Given the crucial role of nutrition in these conditions, the center provides specialized dietary advice aimed at improving eating habits and rectifying nutritional deficiencies. This guidance is not just about prescribing diets but also involves educating patients about nutrition and helping them develop healthier relationships with food.
  • Psychological Support: The center places a strong emphasis on addressing the psychological aspects underlying eating disorders. Therapy sessions are a core component of the treatment, aimed at understanding and tackling the root causes of the disorder, such as anxiety, fear, or past trauma related to eating and food.
  • Family Engagement: Recognizing the pivotal role of family support in the recovery process, the Kahm Center actively involves family members in the treatment. This approach helps build a supportive home environment and provides family members with the tools and knowledge to assist their loved ones effectively.
  • Meal Support: Meal support is an integral part of the treatment process, especially for individuals with ARFID. It involves supervised meal sessions where patients receive real-time support and guidance in managing their eating behaviors. This approach helps in normalizing eating patterns, reducing anxiety around meal times, and ensuring adequate nutritional intake.

The Kahm Center is committed to providing specialized care that differentiates ARFID from picky eating, ensuring accurate diagnosis and treatment for each condition. This dedication is crucial in helping individuals overcome the challenges associated with these eating behaviors. For more information on how to overcome ARFID and the services and programs offered at the Kahm Center, interested parties are encouraged to contact the center directly.

Clinically Reviewed By

nick kahm reviewer

Nick Kahm, PhD


Nick Kahm, a former philosophy faculty member at St. Michael's College in Colchester, VT, transitioned from academia to running the Kahm Clinic with his mother. He started the clinic to train dietitians in using Metabolic Testing and Body Composition Analysis for helping people with eating disorders. Now, he is enthusiastic about expanding eating disorder treatment through the Kahm Center for Eating Disorders in Vermont.

Looking for treatment?

We're Here to Help!
Call for Assessment